Hand-sliced cold cuts, hot heroes off the grill, fresh-pulled mozzarella, and catering for every occasion.
Hot Heroes Off the Grill
Catering Trays for Any Crowd
Bread in by 6am
Three Generations Behind the Counter
Hot Heroes Off the Grill Catering Trays for Any Crowd Bread in by 6am Three Generations Behind the Counter
Authentic Italian Deli
A real taste of the old Bronx neighborhood, right here in Mahopac for over 30 years.
Open 7 days a week · 8am–7pm · fresh heroes, prepared foods, and the deli counter.
Order online for pickup, or get it delivered through DoorDash.
WHAT WE’RE KNOWN FOR
The Fresh Mozzarella people drive in for.
Pulled fresh every single morning, the way it's done in the old neighborhood. Creamy, milky, and nothing like the supermarket stuff. It's the reason regulars come back, and the first thing we'd tell you to try.
The Menu
Made Fresh, The Way It Should Be
CATERING
We bring the deli to you
From office lunches to backyard parties — hero platters, antipasti spreads, hot trays, and everything in between.
Family-run for over 30 years
OUR STORY
Arthur Ave Deli opened its doors in Mahopac in 1994, named for the legendary Bronx street where our family first learned the trade. We've been slicing prosciutto, pressing fresh mozzarella, and building heroes the same way ever since.
From the Neighborhood
Don’t Just Take Our Word for It
Follow along @arthuravedeli
